Listen to the audio summary of the article
Listen on Spreaker.
Lake Naivasha is located in Kenya, a few dozen kilometers from Nairobi, and is home to a curious geographical phenomenon: an island that is not always such. It’s called Crescent Island, it’s what remains of an extinct volcano and, although it’s called “Crescent Island”, sometimes it’s… a peninsula.
The waters of Lake Naivasha, in fact, tend to rise or fall based on the climate: when they are low enough, Crescent Island is connected to the mainland by a strip of land. However, this has not happened since 2020: six years ago the waters rose, submerging the connection, and since then the animals on the island have lived in a “paradise” almost free of predators. A study published in Frontiers in Sustainable Tourismhowever, reveals that the situation is less rosy than one would expect.
The island that is not always an island
Crescent Island has lived up to its name for six years now, and in 2025 a group of researchers from St. George’s University, Canada, visited it to check the situation of the local fauna, now cut off from the mainland.
The first thing they noticed was an almost total lack of predators: the two most present species are otocyones (small African foxes) and black-backed jackals; both feed on small prey, and leave larger animals alone.
That’s why these animals have multiplied in recent years: after being cut off from the mainland, Crescent Island has seen an exponential growth in impala, waterbuck, zebra, even giraffe and hippo.
Only some of these species are able to swim back and forth from the mainland, for example zebras: all the others have been trapped on site since 2020. One would think that there are worse places from which one cannot escape, but the ecological situation of Crescent Island says otherwise.
Trouble in Paradise
The presence of large herbivorous species, whose numbers have grown precisely due to the absence of predators, has created enormous problems for the vegetation, which, due to being grazed without having time to regrow, has almost disappeared from entire areas of the island.
The increasingly degraded vegetation has forced herbivores to look for other sources of food, in many cases provided directly by the island’s control staff.
The collapse of plant biodiversity has also promoted competition between species for scarce food, and has also caused the spread of diseases: the island’s gazelles, for example, suffer from an as yet unidentified disease.
The authors of the study explain, however, that theirs are, for now, only observations, not real censuses: more solid numbers will be needed to establish a conservation plan for the island, which could include, for example, a guided ecosystem restoration, the creation of an artificial passage towards the mainland and perhaps even the reintroduction of predators.
